As I mentioned in a previous review, using the "theological giants" as a source of authority can be problematic.
Martin Luther, for example, is often quoted as saying fewer than "one in a thousand" men are truly suited for celibacy.
But I ran across a humorous quote from the same work, The Estate of Marriage:
To sum the matter up: whoever finds himself unsuited to the celibate life should see to it right away that he has something to do and to work at; then let him strike out in God's name and get married. A young man should marry at the age of twenty at the latest, a young woman at fifteen to eighteen; that's when they are still in good health and best suited for marriage. Let God worry about how they and their children are to be fed. God makes children; he will surely also feed them. Should he fail to exalt you and them here on earth, then take satisfaction in the fact that he has granted you a Christian marriage, and know that he will exalt you there; and be thankful to him for his gifts and favours.
Would anyone consider this sound advice on marriage in our current context--telling young women to marry at 15? I sincerely doubt it.
In fairness to Luther, it was a different time--men were finished with their education (if any) much earlier. But that's my point--we must be careful in interpreting and applying his thoughts.
Don't get me wrong--I think we can still learn much from those who have gone before us and wrestled with theological issues. But let's not forget something: even "theological giants" were only men.



4 comments:
I agree that it was a different time but I think it would've been still irresponsible to leave the feeding of the offspring to God alone.
"Let God worry about how they and their children are to be fed. God makes children; he will surely also feed them."
Does he mean to not plan family and just have sex as the couple pleases and have a dozen of kids they probably won't be able to provide for? A bit too spiritual and extreme there.
Thess,
Well, Luther lived in a different time--a time. Even a few decades ago, more children were helpful because you had more help on the farm. Life was just more simple back then.
But you are seeing the point of this article--we have to use caution in applying theologians' points of view.
I really appreciate this, because I personally don't believe the church should be pressuring singles to get married resting on the shoulders of "theological giants". I also don't believe that one should look at the current cultural climate and then embrace tradition with a blindly nostalgic view of the past in regards to marriage and family.
wats up wat u doing
Post a Comment